Property Description

HISTORIC CHURCH BUILDING with original, untouched, Pews, Sanctuary, Pulpit, Cast Iron Bell with Ringing Cord, Bell Tower and Stained Glass Windows. PLUS, separate Storage Building used as Fellowship Hall! Site is .71 Acres with spacious Parking Lot. Located near Seneca Lake in the heart of NY's Finger Lakes Region. Himrod offers small-town charm with rolling vineyard views, lakefront recreation, and easy access to wineries, farm markets, and dining. Conveniently located between Penn Yan, Watkins Glen, and Geneva, it's a hidden gem where country living meets Finger Lakes lifestyle. LIVE AUCTION SALE ON SITE - Saturday, 4/18/26 at 11:00 AM. Starting bid $25,000. Winning bidder must sign Auction Purchase Contract at the auction and provide a minimum 10% deposit (cash or check). Closing required on or before 7/31/26. Seller reserves the right to review and confirm the high bid. Written, electronic, and proxy bids accepted prior to the sale. The Himrod Baptist Church is listed on the New York State and National Historic Registers. Any renovation, alteration, or change of use USING NYS OR FEDERAL FUNDS will require applicable historic preservation approvals. Projects completed without State or Federal funding are NOT subject to those approval requirements. Local Town of Milo requirements will apply for renovation and/or change of use.

Property Features

Local Schools